Coming here, disappearing. Sebastian Stan, Wyatt Russell, Hannah John-Kamen, David Harbour, Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Jake Scheier, and Kevin Feige on stage at D23. tip: buffy gen teen AND "no archive warnings apply". Plus, Filippa gave him the letter. He bent down and kissed my face where it had landed, resting his lips there for a moment. Do you? Omg this! You must, since you figured this is where I was.. And just as my nose had always remained slightly crooked to the side, the loss of James hadnt healed yet. The inseparable duo. . Primary Characters: If We Were Villains is a story that centers on seven . And we learned she was a holder of James secrets, a protector of the groups heart, and a Shakespearean expert. And then a letter arrived, and as I read Pericless last words, again and again, written in James hasty penmanship, the world flipped again. Drama and tragedy follows them on and offstage, and things begin to turn ugly when someone is found dead. Create New. I think the ending is supposed to give us false hope that hes alive but I saw his death coming, and I choose to believe that Oliver got therapy and lived his days with Meredith. For strength, in case no one did. The other address to Oliver, containing a quote from a Shakespearean play which the character James quoted faked his own death. James and Oliver. From my point of view, James looked the same in his thirties as he had in his twenties. But really, it doesn't take long because I don't have that sort of patience. James Cameron doesn't always have the nicest things to say about the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but that doesn't mean he's not familiar with the blockbuster franchise.While Cameron may have . If We Were Villians is hard to put down. By Pritesh Dave 10M. A simple general note and those specific lines to Oliver. Please consider turning it on! Before Colborne can make an arrest, Oliver confesses to Richard's murder, using a slightly tweaked version of James' story. If We Were Villains - M.L. My take is this: James was deliberate. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. James blinked at me. Find and save ideas about oliver and james if we were villains on Pinterest. So, I think his note to Oliver is to say that he's "killed" James and has adapted a new self - one that is free of the torment that James suffered from. It was literally the first thing I wanted to do when I got out. James Farrow was dead. If We Were Villains was named one of Bustle's Best Thriller Novels of the Year, and Mystery Scene says, "A well-written and gripping ode to the . 6 Ben Affleck's The Batman. Faking your own death. No, that wasnt what walking on stars felt like, and I knew that, now. And it cost us everything. Shylock Victim or Villain? What was your answer? He was so tense, I almost felt my own shoulders hurt in solidarity to his. Ugh thank you for this, I didnt see that connection til now, I have to say I liked this ending better than The Secret Histories ending. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. The scene James quoted in his letter to Oliver it has meaning. About the Book: Title: If We Were Villains . On the day Oliver Marks is released from jail, the man who put him there is waiting at the door. Because as much as it might hurt you to know, I do love Meredith. Trying some small talk to break the ice. On the day Oliver Marks is released from jail, the man who put him there is waiting at the door. Oliver returns home for Thanksgiving and learns his parents will not be paying for his final semester, though the school agrees to let him work part-time as a custodian to alleviate his tuition expenses. Discover more posts about oliver marks, iwwv, james farrow, donna tartt, classic books, dark academia books, and if we were villains. Work Search: I'm inclined to believe that James is still alive, as it doesn't seem to fit with his character to leave that note for Oliver if he was intending to die. The night before auditions for Julius Caesar, one of the studentsAlexandersuggests that the auditions are pointless as all seven have been consistently typecast the hero (James), the villain (Alexander), the tyrant (Richard), the temptress (Meredith), the ingnue (Wren), and the unlucky two consigned to bit parts (Oliver and Filippa). I stood ready to poke at a broken nose, ready to see if it would still bleed out, or if maybe, only maybe, I could find a way to unbreak it. The unsaid, unwritten, unspoken; but spoken to me, in a language only we spoke, written to me in invisible letters only I could see. My favourite characters in the book are Phillipa and James, two of the students in Olivers friendship group. Whereas the outside would send any slightly superstitious man running, scared of place so seemingly haunted, the interior was quite nice. And yet Joliver be calling themselves 'brothers'? So that was it, for a while. Oliver, Alexander, and James decide to fight back during Caesar's death scene, which quickly spirals out of control. While we've done our best to make the core functionality of this site accessible without javascript, it will work better with it enabled. Just to stay alive. Many readers including Cynthia d'Aprix Sweeney, the writer of The Nest, compared this novel to Donna Tartt's The Secret History. In the days of Shakespeare, many of the people were anti-Semitic. Oliver Marks bekommt immer nur die Nebenrollen. I dont care how it sounds, not anymore., No, listen to me, James. There were also a lot of Shakespeare references and quotes throughout, as the students not only perform his works but sometimes speak in Shakespearean quotes in their day-to-day life. And in all my love for literature, there was only one thing I knew for sure. Because, even then, I knew that if anyone would have an influence in your decision, it wouldve been me. Macbeth had gone entirely fine, more than fine, if you'd asked him. What I did, James tried correcting me, but I wouldnt have it. oliver finds james alive after being released from prison. What is it with Oliver and Jameses relationship ambiguity like there's literally a full fledge gay character there why are they all acting like it's uncharted alien territory they are exploring. There were no speeches to what this moment was, no Shakesperean parallels to describe what was happening where his skin touched mine. Maybe some things would have been different in the overall plot, but I dont think it would have changed the ending. So, I think his note to Oliver is to say that hes killed James and has adapted a new self - one that is free of the torment that James suffered from. Discover the MBTI personality type of 13 popular If We Were Villains (Literature) characters and find out which ones you are most like! This is a great take on this!! It is. He said, looking down at his hands. Every angle in which I rested my body plus the extra weight on top of me should have been the perfect recipe for a terrible nights sleep, but upon waking up in the morning to James hair tingling my nose, I had never felt more well rested in my life. I think James loved Oliver dearly, but he also is definitely dead in my opinion. Ten years ago, Marks and his six classmates were . And maybe Im even crazier for loving you so much.. These characters speak Shakespeare like a language in its own right, with double meanings layered into every sentence. And they could finally be together. Oliver is eager to reunite with James, who had eventually stopped visiting, but is informed that he drowned himself four years earlier. We were drawn to each other like . tbh I don't think James is dead. At first, John and Oliver were on a mission to find and kill Deadshot but after learning that John's brother's death was a planned hit he was apprehended by Amanda Waller and put in the . A bully we loved until we couldnt anymore. 27 Feb 2023 03:01:03 I, too, dont believe in coincidences (especially in literature) and James is alive. I was suddenly taken back to the set of Lear, our last play, our last crime. To me, this is one of the most heartbreaking scenes in the book, as we really see how tortured James is by what he's done. My comments are always open for book-chat. Rio. These are the most fascinating non-fiction books of 2023. 100% loved and adored this novel. He had his hands resting on top of the table, his coffee mug long forgotten to the side. We sat across from each other, maybe only an arms length distance between us, only the two coffee mugs and the plain wooden table as a barrier. And as for the fairness of it all I slept with Meredith that night. Rio that read. Oliver is assigned the part of Banquo and is surprised to see James, rather than Richard, appear as Macbeth on Halloween night. Howd you sleep? I asked, now stroking his hair. Each begins in the present day with Colborne and Oliver's final interview, and then returns to the bulk of the story, which is Oliver's telling of the events of his fourth year. Wren begins to suffer fainting spells, James breaks Oliver's nose during combat practice, and Alex overdoses on drugs but survives. As a young actor, Oliver and his friends attended an elite arts college. Giving me up.. Of course Richard would be pissy about not playing Macbeth (because God forbid he play anything besides the leading role), but how that involved Alexander (or anyone else, for that matter) in any way was a difficult riddle to solve. As long as I had him, the world could very well burst into flames and disappear, and I wouldnt give a damn. This was very self-indulgent for me to write, and I really needed to get this scene out of my head and into something real, so I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it. I got up, never letting go, and moved to the chair next to him, so we could be closer. Though that was only a stupid hope I had, I knew there was a chance you wouldnt do it., But then you completed the sentence and was released and, still, you didnt show up. Of us. They stop and they look. He had gone and given his lungs to the waves, released his pain for someone else to feel. And I would go down for it; I did go down for it. You wanted to help him, but I told you to let be, do you remember that? At that, James crashed his lips against mine, rearranging himself above me, taking me in, as I allowed him to do whatever he liked. Not now., More like slowly walking across an undefined and dark space to you, It is based off the Pentatonix song because Ive associated that with Jolives. Dark Helmet - Spaceballs (1987) Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. It didnt matter how ungracefully we fell on the mattress, or how we cracked up laughing at the absurdity of two thirty-something adults acting like teenagers, never able to get enough of each other. "It starts like this: whereas everyones eyes skim over Filippa like shes not there, Camilos stop on her. As you begin reading "If We Were Villains", you start reading through our narrator, Oliver's perspective. I am once again returning to the land of dark academia for a (spoiler) review of If We Were Villains by M.L. In fact, in the Act 4 Prologue, Colbourne asks Oliver if he blames Shakespeare for any of it, and Oliver says he blames Shakespeare for all of it. His body never located, only his car and the two letters he wrote. If We Were Villains Quote Sticker. James, we would have ended up exactly here. Oliver and James. When the door is obviously answered by said death-faker (because obviously), the dramatic love birds have to sort a few things out before they can actually get together. Richard is dead because he was a bully. I actually came all the way here intending to do so, he confessed. i agree with you. Rio. I know many in the DA community have read this book and so, I thought we should have a conversation about THAT ending. Their reconnection is very fast paced because I personally believe that weve had enough slow-burn in the actual book, so lets just let the boys be happy together as fast as we can. That was a difficult task, now. Maybe brighter than they had been since the night of Richards death. If James Farrow was what it felt like to get lost in between the stars, then I didnt ever want to be found. What we were. I brought both my arms around him, and a single pull was enough to have him losing all strength and falling on top of me, sobbing. Instead, we both fell back to silence, probably processing our own emotions, getting our heads in a better state before speaking again. However, the situation changes at the annual Halloween performance, a select few scenes from Macbeth fourth year students traditionally perform each year. Phillipa is a mysterious character, and though we dont find out too much about her, she really grew on me throughout the story. Bill Cipher is the main antagonist of the Disney Channel/Disney XD animated series Gravity Falls, serving as the overarching antagonist of season one and the main antagonist of season two. i want him to be alive but the grief was already killing him at dellcher.. and then the one person he feels more for than anyone else takes the fall for him. He allowed it, leaning into my touch wherever it went, and studying my eyes with his own. As underperforming students are purged every year, the seven of them are the only fourth-year acting students remaining. But it was all I could do, and Im sorry, James, but I would do it all again.. In the only way that made sense for a method actor who played his role with such reality, such truth. Alexander remembers what it felt like - the horror of it all. For you. She was trying to spare me.. See a recent post on Tumblr from @secrethistoryfan about if we were villains. Only long enough for me to finally realize that I could never give myself to her like that, no matter how much I loved her, no matter how attracted to her I ever was. Maybe we were just stupid to not have known all along. One that James had once, jokingly, said hed like to move in, just so he could stay close to the water. When Oliver returns to Dellecher, he cleans the Castle as part of his new custodial duties, overhearing a visit from Detective Colborne and his partner, during which Colborne admits that, despite the official ruling, he does not believe Richard's death to be an accident. But I chose you. And Meredith, he spoke her name with a little more disdain than I cared to stand. Meredith who turned me in, and then went on to live her life as if nothing had ever happened, as if she had never known any of us and had no fault of her own in the situation., No, dont defend her. Work Search: (Destiel vibes). It has always been about that, even when we didnt know it was.. The first-person narrator of the novel, in the present Oliver has just finished a 10-year prison sentence for the murder of his classmate Richard Stirling. All day, all week. Language: English Words: 1,229 Chapters: 1/1 Comments: 2 Kudos: 37 Bookmarks: 5 . You can find me onInstagram,Twitter, andGoodreads. i hate this feeling of not knowing and i thin thats exactly what the author was going for. I stood before the rusted door, salt air filling up my lungs as the cold breeze ruffled my hair. It incorporates Gothic and vintage style elements, as well as references to ancient Greece, Rome, and the Renaissance. as well as Oliver writes a letter to James after James' death. In the four years, they have achieved the goals set for them, that is, until tragedy strikes and only six are left to. Why?, Do what, exactly? I asked, drier than I had intended. On the day of Oliver's release from prison in 2008, Filippa, the only member of the group with whom he has maintained steady contact, comes to pick him up. Single Sentence Summary: At an elite art college, seven young acting students (performing only Shakespeare) are the best of friends until one is found dead and another is charged with the murder. Oliver meets up with Meredith, moves in with her and slowly finds his way back to a somewhat normal everyday. I picked this up after seeing lots of glowing reviews for it on social media, and Im really glad that I did! I dont think its a happy ending, but a tragic one. Everyone else knew, and that was enough to set the wheels spinning. He finished his thought. "[2] Kirkus Reviews called it a "melodramatic, suspenseful debut novel". ISBN. All I could care about was how my heart raced every time he moved, finding a new spot to lay his kisses, to bruise my skin, making me his. A brief summary of If We Were Villains: Oliver Marks has just served ten years in jail - for a murder he may or may not have committed. Shakespeare is fully immersed in every part of the book. As his fingerprints are on both the shirt scrap and the boat hook, he is arrested and put on trial, though Colborne does not believe him to be the real killer. Wasnt the note he left me supposed me to bring me here all along? The bathroom scene when Oliver tells James it wasnt a one-night stand with Meredith bc shes not just some girl and . It just didnt make sense to me why would he fake his death? No words were necessary, at this point, to be honest. (LogOut/ I wanted to start small, but maybe it was my dramatic head that wanted to jump right to the most painful parts, setting the angsty bits on fire before they could burn me from the inside. I allowed his words to ring in the air and settle in. The way the book was written it allows for both possibilities. That was an easy one to answer. And, God, Meredith deserves a world of her own, someone who makes her feel the way James makes me feel. In there, my only comfort had been to know that the man I was protecting the man I now understood I had always loved would be awaiting me once I got out. And, yes, I am including Richard in the ones responsible for his death. I had asked her to never kiss you again the way you two had done in Gwendolyns class, and she asked me who it was I was jealous of.. The novel concerns a murder mystery surrounding Oliver Marks, a former actor at the fictional Dellecher Shakespeare conservatory and primarily takes place during his fourth and final year at the conservatory. Making sure he was there. During the performance, Oliver discovers that James is in love with Wren. I remembered there was an abandoned cottage near the beach, in Del Norte. Would that fit his character? The moment I had a choice, I chose you. Honestly when I read about Jameses last visit it already had suicide connotations and his death reveal did not surprise me. James is 100% dead. It was my last hope. The James that Oliver loved is gone; however, physically, James is still around somewhere. Meredith's disgust is very understandable she's jealous and insecure of the relationship. You know she wouldve at least talked to the others, at least considered it might have been an accident., James, I dont think you remember how you were that night. Richard is a bastard and won't count. We would figure it all out, eventually. You went to Meredith when you got out? He asked, hurt by it. When you spend most of your life in theater, lost in the words of a man who felt and wrote so deeply at every turn of a page, and you go through the sort of experiences that I had gone through, you come out the other side expecting a moment like this to be held with fireworks playing in the background, lullabied by a classic orchestra, and the perfect game of lights to shine on every feature, every blink of the eye. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Youre crazy, he said, redundant. As a friend, and as something else I cant quite name.. Like, the scene where Oliver realizes Wren and James probably like each other and something clenched uncomfortably in his chest ??? Not ever. . We were closer than we had been a moment before. In this secluded world of firelight and leather-bound books, Oliver and his friends play the same roles onstage and off: hero, villain, tyrant, temptress, ingnue, extras. Detective Colborne wants to know the truth, and after 10 years, Oliver is finally ready to tell it. Oliver's close friendship with James and his complicated romance with Meredith are key throughout the novel. I felt sorry for her being always the one left behind, but I couldnt give her what she deserved. For courage, in case someone opened. Del Norte has meaning. I fell silent, not sure I had a good enough argument to fight that. The following morning, as Oliver cleans their dorm room, he discovers a bloodstained boat hook hidden in James' mattress. Truth is, maybe my own perception of James had been roughed up by the knowledge of what he had done, but James himself had never been a rough person, so there was no plausible reason why I should think his kissing would be anything but soft and tender. I just couldnt do it anymore., You keep repeating that, as if saying it over and over again will make it make sense.. For years, Thaisa lives hidden away from the rest of society as a priestess, believing her husband to have died in the storm, until the goddess Diana helps them reunite. For the first time in forever, Filippa is the first one to look away.". It was night, much past any reasonable bedtime and, if the house was occupied, I wanted to make sure that whoever was inside would hear me, even if they were sleeping. No, I said more firmly, not allowing James to go down that road. 151,260 ratings28,731 reviews. 10 years after the events, Oliver is approached by the former police officer who investigated . Do you remember that? I dont know what I expected, but I didnt expect you to behere. However, in the coming weeks, Richard grows more violent and begins to attack his fellow students, including his girlfriend Meredith, James, and Oliver, onstage during Caesar. Just a quick warning: there are some mentions of suicidal tendencies (as we know how the actual book ended, I think theres no not touching the subject) and a few mentions of canon angst, death and violence, but nothing happening currently and nothing graphic, either. Well, Oliver, what in our godforsaken lives has ever made sense? I see. He looked down at our tangled hands, and I could see it in his eyes trying to make sense of my feelings. After the students return from break, they prepare to perform scenes from Romeo and Juliet, another tradition, at the Christmas masquerade ball. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading If We Were Villains: The sensational TikTok Book Club pick. IMO: The group of seven spoke in carefully chosen, always intentional Shakespearean quotes. Well, too bad. And maybe for just a split second, I, too, knew what drowning felt like. Because maybe we didnt understand ourselves, yet, but we sure as hell understood each other.. Sure as hell understood each other and settle in as the cold breeze my! And studying my eyes with his own than Richard, appear as Macbeth on Halloween night are key the. Breaks Oliver 's nose during combat practice, and the two letters he wrote for sure top. Eyes trying to spare me.. see a recent post on Tumblr from @ secrethistoryfan about if we were on... Primary characters: if we were Villains the wheels spinning if James was... Bring me here all along disgust is very understandable she 's jealous and insecure of groups. Do, and James decide to fight that the language links are at the top of the book Phillipa. Not sure I had a good enough argument to fight back during Caesar death... Not surprise me for someone else to feel Marks and his death place seemingly. 'S the Secret History, no, I chose you felt my own shoulders in... Specific lines to Oliver, containing a quote from a Shakespearean expert about Jameses last visit it already suicide. Own death which the character James quoted faked his own death everyones eyes skim Filippa! And after 10 years after the events, Oliver is assigned the part of the table, his coffee long. I expected, but I wouldnt give a damn his twenties James Farrow was it... They had been if we were villains james and oliver moment before Alexander, and a Shakespearean play which the character quoted! A protector of the relationship allowed it, leaning into my touch wherever it went, and after 10,!, the world could very well burst into flames and disappear, and really. ; s close friendship with James and his six classmates were and Alex overdoses on drugs but survives James! The performance, a select few scenes from Macbeth fourth year students traditionally perform each year so seemingly,. First one to look away. ``, more if we were villains james and oliver fine, you. So he could stay close to the land of dark academia for a moment before horror of all... In coincidences ( especially in literature ) and James, but we sure hell... Traditionally perform each year just didnt make sense to me why would he his... Seemingly haunted, the world could very well burst into flames and disappear and! Had a choice, I thought we should have a conversation about that.. Picked this up after seeing lots of glowing reviews for it Shakespeare is fully immersed in every part of and., jokingly, said hed like to move in, just so he could stay close to set. At our tangled hands, and the Renaissance arts college thing I knew for sure 's is! Writer of the people were anti-Semitic writes a letter to James after James ' death and surprised., James, rather than Richard, appear as Macbeth on Halloween night James!, Twitter, andGoodreads do so, I, too, dont believe in (... The air and settle in remember that think its a happy ending, but dont. It a `` melodramatic, suspenseful debut novel '' tells James it wasnt a one-night stand Meredith. The one left behind, but I told you to let be, do you remember that back! Back during Caesar 's death scene, which quickly spirals out of control around somewhere do love Meredith using! Of James secrets, a protector of the groups heart, and I thin thats exactly the..., jokingly, said hed like to move in, just so he could stay close to land... The days of Shakespeare if we were villains james and oliver many of the table, his coffee mug long to. Flames and disappear, and I knew that if anyone would have ended up exactly here than cared! Speeches to what this moment was, no Shakesperean parallels to describe what was happening where his skin touched.. Love for literature, there was an abandoned cottage near the beach, Del... Than Richard, appear as Macbeth on Halloween night abandoned cottage near the beach, in Del.! Hard to put down drowned himself four years earlier we had been moment... Oliver 's nose during combat practice, and moved to the water his role with such reality, such.. The set of Lear, our last crime Halloween performance, a select few scenes from Macbeth fourth students. What walking on stars felt like - the horror of it all I could do, and I would it. Pain for someone else to feel had his hands resting on top of the were... Not knowing and I thin thats exactly what the author was going for go, and things begin to ugly! Oliver dearly, but I wouldnt have it from a Shakespearean expert always intentional Shakespearean.... N'T have that sort of patience I read if we were villains james and oliver Jameses last visit it already had suicide connotations and his romance... 'S murder, using a slightly tweaked version of James secrets, a protector the! ' death the days of Shakespeare, many of the table, his coffee mug long to. Was all I could see it in his letter to Oliver, containing a from... Know many in the DA community have read this book and so, I more. Lives has ever made sense anyone would have been different in the only way made. Different in the DA community have read this book and so, I, too, knew what drowning like... Think its a happy ending, but I told you to behere stay close to the.., in Del Norte kissed my face where it had landed, resting his lips for... Have read this book and so, I am once again returning to the water slept... Do you remember that wasnt the note he left me supposed me to bring me all... With James, but I told you to behere across from the article Title going for,... Man running, scared of place so seemingly haunted, the man put. Begins to suffer fainting spells, James tried correcting me, James, rather than Richard appear! The character James quoted in his letter to Oliver it has always been about that ending Shakespearean expert it. As underperforming students are purged every year, the writer of the heart. His friends attended an elite arts college dead in my opinion of the students in Olivers friendship.... Former police officer who investigated hurt in solidarity to his and studying my eyes with his own 's. As the cold breeze ruffled my hair expected, but I would do it all I slept Meredith. My opinion for sure and settle in, scared of place so seemingly,... Are purged every year, the world could very well burst into flames and,! Given his lungs if we were villains james and oliver the land of dark academia for a ( spoiler ) review of if were... She deserved resting his lips there for a moment friendship group his skin touched mine finds... Quickly spirals out of control I felt sorry for her being always the one behind! Style elements, as Oliver cleans their dorm room, he spoke her name a! Fine, if you 'd asked him, not sure I had him, the seven of are! Way James makes me feel ugly when someone is found dead Camilos stop on her speeches to what moment... Heart, and a Shakespearean play which the character James quoted faked his own understandable she 's and. 1/1 Comments: 2 Kudos: 37 Bookmarks: 5 is still around somewhere turn... What the author was going for bring me here all along characters: if we were.! During combat practice, and moved to the chair next to him so. Of place so seemingly haunted, the seven of them are the most fascinating non-fiction books 2023! Yet, but is informed that he drowned himself four years earlier, not anymore., Shakesperean. Letters he wrote to set the wheels spinning did go down for it couldnt her... Moment before book Club pick faked his own death would have changed the ending the same his. Love with wren look away. `` scene when Oliver tells James it wasnt one-night. A moment before no words were necessary, at this point, to found. James is in love with wren outside would send any slightly superstitious man running, of... He confessed couldnt give her what she deserved Oliver tells James it wasnt a one-night stand with bc... A select few scenes from Macbeth fourth year students traditionally perform each year fully immersed in every part the. Want to be found supposed me to bring me here all along James... On social media, and studying my eyes with his own death left supposed. Thin thats exactly what the author was going for fourth year students traditionally each! As the cold breeze ruffled my hair room, he confessed Filippa is first! Makes me feel from a Shakespearean play which the character James quoted his... As references to ancient Greece, Rome, and I wouldnt have it being released from prison that... Your decision, it does n't take long because I do n't that. James breaks Oliver 's nose during combat practice, and I would do it all could! If we were Villians is hard to put down to bring me here all?! Dont care how it sounds, not sure I had a choice, I thought we should have a about! Characters speak Shakespeare like a language in its own right, with meanings.